Näytetään tekstit, joissa on tunniste Bottom Balancing. Näytä kaikki tekstit
Näytetään tekstit, joissa on tunniste Bottom Balancing. Näytä kaikki tekstit

keskiviikko 13. toukokuuta 2020

Gave up and installed a BMS

Yes, it's true. I gave up and installed a BMS. A Battery Monitoring System, that is. Not the kind that drains a few of your cells and then their buddies destroy them at the earliest opportunity. No, the kind the measures two voltages. Whole pack voltage and half pack (more or less).

 The brains of my BMS.

In my case the half pack is the first 13 cells. What this gives me is four interesting figures:

  • Average cell voltage (total voltage divided by number of cells)
  • Average cell voltage for the first 13 cells (their total voltage divided by 13)
  • Average cell voltage for the last 12 cells (total voltage minus first 13 cells divided by 12)
  • Difference in average voltage between first 13 and last 12 cells.
That last bit of information is very interesting, because if it is more than say 0.2 volts, there must be a problem with one of the cells in either part of the pack. All data goes to my Zabbix server, which can alert me, if that happens. I also have Grafana set up, so I can some pretty graphs too.

Now you may ask how do I measure the first 13 cells and not cause an imbalance? Well done, my young Padawan, that is the right question. Well, I have a relay in the loop, which only connects the first 13 cells for a very short time, less than a second, currently every three minutes. The load imposed on the first 13 cells is also something like 0.1 watts. This should not cause a problem even in the long run. And if it does, I'll know about it.

I've used a LinkIt Smart 7688 Duo for a couple of IoT things now, so that's what I used here too. You can get easy to user Grove parts with sensors and the like from Seeed. They're really quite handy if you're as lazy as me and don't want to be soldering every last thing yourself.

Solar controller for charging the car.

I also now charge the car on solar. I have a couple of panels installed which actually charge my motorcycle first and from there I can charge the car, if it pleases me. But more on that later. The motorcycle has had a bit of a make-over as well. It's been about two years since the last post, so if you waited this long, perhaps you can wait a bit more for those as well. Anyway, good times.

ps. Don't pay attention to the grounding cable on the battery box. I've been meaning to hide it for six years now. It's going to happen any day now. Really. Maybe.

lauantai 28. helmikuuta 2015

Update on cell testing

Just a quick update regarding my previous posts on the SE40AHA cells that seemed to be fine after all. So far, in testing the cells by draining them to about 2.6 volts I've found that out of the 33 cells I have, nine seem to have internal shorts. I can tell this by leaving the cells at 2.6 volts and monitoring their voltage. The bad cells have gone down in voltage, some already below 2 volts. They must therefore have internal shorts. The better cells have bounced back a little and then kept their voltage.

So it looks like I might have 24 usable cells. Unfortunately this doesn't really match anything I have in use. The car, Xsara or kWsara, has 25 cells in series, and the motorcycle, kWsaki, is set up for 29 cells with it's 102.2 volt charger. So it's either figure out something else to do with the cells, get a new charger perhaps, or try to find a couple of SE40AHA cells. Unfortunately GWL Power doesn't list them anymore. They are a couple of generations old now, so it's understandable that they'll be unavailable. Sinopoly has similar black 40 Ah cells, which might do just fine, though.

sunnuntai 15. helmikuuta 2015

Lessons learned

A couple of things I learned from the events described in my previous post.
  1. Cells at zero volts may not be dead after all
  2. Cells at zero volts will not charge from a full cell connected in parallel
  3. Bloated cells may actually shrink back to size
  4. Bloating does not automatically mean internal soft shorts
  5. CALB LiFePO4 cells can take hell of a beating
Point number two also casts a shadow on parallel bottom balancing. I think it probably still works if you start with cells in roughly equal voltage, definitely all cells above the bottom balancing voltage, but it will not cause lower voltage cells to rise to a higher voltage (or charge from it's buddies).

Magic recoveries


Remember the 29 cells in my motorcycle I destroyed last summer, when I accidentally left it turned on and the DC/DC converter has drained all the cells to empty and beyond? Something interesting has happened since. Actually, two interesting things.

I was actually going to take most of these cells in for recycling, but I just hadn't got around to it. Instead I had just left them in our basement. Before storing them I had connected them all in series and drained them down to 2.6 volts, figuring that they would bottom balance together and I'd see which cells had internal soft shorts.

Now the eight newest cells I had just bought to increase the cell count to 29 were at zero volts after my little mishap. I had also connected them in parallel with the others, figuring that they'd recharge from the other cells if they had any life in them. They hadn't and I had left them for dead at zero volts.

But before I get to those eight newer cells, let's get back the 22 older cells which had bloated. Actually 12 of them hadn't and I had connected them into three 12 V packs for whatever use I'd come up with later. I even tested them and each 12 V pack had more or less 500 Wh of capacity, so I thought these 12 cells can be saved for later use and the rest scrapped.

The remaining 10 old cells were pretty well bloated, but they seemed to retain voltage, at least for a while. To my no small amazement, they still had the same voltage after about six months of storage. All ten cells were around 2.55 volts. What that means is that they can't have any significant internal shorts. If they had, they'd keep going down until they're at zero volts. Alas they hadn't. What's even more amazing, they had lost their considerable swell and are now pretty much right size and shape! The had actually shrunk back to shape.


Back to the eight newer cells I'd left sitting for half a year at zero volts. I had even been so sure of their fate, that I had liberally sprayed some gold paint on them to mark them as the ones I'd definitely take to the recycling center.

After discovering that the older cells had gotten back to shape and were still holding their charge, I thought I'd give these cells one more chance too. What if they just didn't want to charge from the other cells while being in parallel? I made two 12 V packs of them, measured a voltage of about 0.5 V for both whole packs and connected a 14 V 5 A power supply.

What happened was that the voltage started to steadily rise as one might expect, so I just left them charging for four hours. When I got back, I disconnected the power supply and checked the cell voltages. They seemed normal, about 3.33 V, as they should for just charged, half full cells. Again I left the cells, figuring they'd probably start draining themselves. I was, again, quite amazed to find out they had not, but kept a voltage above 3.2 V instead. I repeated the same for the other pack with identical results.

These eight SE40AHA cells which I had left for dead and stored at zero volts for over six months were back as well! Now I don't expect the cells to have their full 40 Ah capacity left and I haven't tested them with a load, but I will bottom balance the rest of the cells now and connected them as a 29 cell pack. Charging them together will reveal if any cells shoot higher too early and what the remaining capacity of the pack is.

Right now it looks like bottom balancing saved the day after all.

perjantai 27. kesäkuuta 2014

Better, yes?


I improved the Air Intake Filtering System (AIFS, as I like to casually call it) a little bit. Still not the prettiest thing on the planet, but a little less protruding at least. I'll try to fix it a little more permanently once I have the new cells in.


On that note I have eight new CALB SE40AHA cells ready to rock. I noticed they have new cool vents with a little round cap on them that says CALB. I'll be sure to put these cells in the motorcycle so that they'll be the most visible ones. As for the bottom balancing, taking place here in the picture, I set my Professional Bottom Balancing Tool (or PBBT) to 2.7 volts, so the cells drained in parallel to 2.69 volts. The next day after disconnecting them from everything, including each other, they were at exactly 2.71 volts each. Shows that doing this in parallel works, all cells are good (bad cells would go down by themselves) and they are quite identical in all intents and purposes.

lauantai 26. huhtikuuta 2014

Rear pack in


I got my SE60AHA cells installed in the back of the car. I decided to put all of them in the back and the 25pcs set of SE40AHA cells in the front. They will be connected in parallel. I have a service on-off switch in the rear pack, so I can turn it off and measure both sides individually to see if they start developing issues. I also need to move my main contactor and measurement shunt to the front as well.

In general the parallel bottom balancing seems to be a success. I ended up turning it off already the next morning, as the meter was switching the relay on and off with the cells bouncing above and below 2.7 volts based on load. I lowered the target voltage 2.6 volts for a little while and they just left them as they were.

All cells were at about 2.636 volts after taking it all apart and the 60 Ah cells bounced up to 2.656 or so, if I recall correctly. 40 Ah cells to less than 2.65 V. A single slightly suspicious cell stayed below 2.64 volts. Not a huge difference, but we'll so it does in the long run. It will also be interesting to see how the different capacity packs react to charge and discharge cycles, but I think it'll be just fine. If it doesn't work out I can always take them out completely and/or get another set of sixties later.

torstai 24. huhtikuuta 2014

Thursday quickie

I got the 60 Ah pack in parallel down to about 2.97 volts and decided it was time to connect it to the parallel pack of the 40 Ah cells. It went fine, no sparks or nothing. Well, some sparks, when the connecting plus cable hit the negative, but that doesn't really count. Anyway, it is done now and the heater based bottom balancer is happily chipping away at the rest of the remaining charge.

I think I'll let it drain the cells for a day or two after it initially hits the target 2.7 V. They'll try to bounce back for some time. Perhaps not so much that there's so many of them, but there does seem to be a about 0.02 volts of difference between the cells at the center and very ends of the packs, which may also take some time to propagate.


sunnuntai 20. huhtikuuta 2014

Parallel balancing

Just thought I'd show you what's going on. The 60 Ah batteries had arrived while I was gone and once I got back I started taking the shipment apart. Everything was there. Including the 25 pcs SE60AHA cells, a 4x20Ah 12V block, interconnects and a PowerLog 6S, which I may or may not need anymore. Thanks to my smallest offspring for helping out.

Couldn't have done with out you.

Having moved the batteries to the basement I proceeded to do a little experiment in parallel bottom balancing. Here I have the 60 Ah cells connected to each other in parallel. The 40 Ah cells are lower in charge, but once I get the sixties closer to them I may go ahead and parallel all of them and then proceed to drain them together to around 2.7 volts. Should be pretty well in balance then.

Sure looks like a lot of cells when you line them up like this.

Oh, one more thing. I thought this was pretty funny. Or sad. Can't decide which.

Personally I'd rather be on a plane with these batteries than most people.


maanantai 14. huhtikuuta 2014

Adventures in bottom balancing


Here's my bottom balancer - take one. The 50W 0.2ohm resistor is attached to a rather large CPU heatsink from a Dell 2U server, complete with heatpipes and thermal paste. Looked sort of nice and ready rock.


The first issues were the little clips heating up rather considerably, so I took them out. Next it seemed like the resistor was getting pretty hot too, so I added a little fan to cool the heatsink. It seemed ok. Also the voltage measured by the device was a lot off compared to a separate voltmeter. Turns out some the connections and the cell fuse were heating up and thus contributing to the error in measurement.


When I got back a bit later I found out that the resistor had given up the ghost. The device was activated, but no amps were drawn. The resistor would have needed more cooling than the little fan was able to produce. Luckily I remembered the rather large heating element from a Citroën C5 which I had purchased earlier to heat up the cabin, but which didn't give enough heat. I gave it a go and what do you know, it ended up consuming about 12 amps from a single cell. Prefect!

Also with extra fuse removed, heavier cables and unnecessary connections taken away the device also now reports correct voltages. I've set it to deactivate the relay at 2.7 volts, which means that it will drain the cell until 2.7 volts is reached and then starts to go on/off in an increasingly rapid manner as it's trying to get the cell to stay at 2.7 volts.

I'm doing this to prepare these old 40 Ah cells for marrying them to the new 60 Ah cells which should be arriving this wekk.

lauantai 22. maaliskuuta 2014

Throttle power supply and a bottom balancer

So I ran in to the problem with the +5V input that the TPS requires. The AXE7245 controller has the throttle input 2 connected to battery negative internally, so I can't use the +5V provided by the original car wiring, since it has negative in chassis ground. I received a cheap 12V to 5V converter I bought from ebay, but as I suspected it wasn't isolated. So I put in an order for a 72V to 12V converter, which I could use to power the 5V converter. That way the isolation is not a problem, because I don't have to connect them to the chassis ground at any point. I've also gathered a number of AC to 5-12VDC converters, which I'll test for use with voltages between 48V and 84V DC. If an old Nokia charger will do the trick, maybe I'll just use one.

In other news I've decided to build a better bottom balancing system. Or actually a bottom balancing system, since before I did it by hand. Then I had 25 40Ah cells, so it wasn't too bad. Now I'll have 50 40-60Ah cells or 25 100Ah cells, and I'd like to do it as well as possible, so an automated system is in order.

The parts needed include a programmable voltmeter and a big resistor. I ordered a 0.2 ohm 50W resistor for a couple of euros and a cheap voltmeter with hopefully usable relay control for about 20 €. Both from ebay. Those two combined with a simple automotive 12V relay and a 12V power supply should be quite capable of draining LiFePO4 cells at about 15A or 50W. I'll just set the voltmeter to disengage the relay at 2.5 V and engage at 2.8 V. I should then end up with a pretty much empty cell resting about 2.75 volts.



sunnuntai 21. heinäkuuta 2013

Call for Top balancers


I'd like to hear from any readers who are using or advocating "Top balancing". Specifically, I'd like to hear how you do it and what science do you think it's based on.

To me it more and more looks like "Top balancing" is something that you can't even do they way you think it can be done. Massaging as much energy in the cells by "boiling" them at a certain voltage doesn't even seem to result in evenly charged cells.

There's a couple of ways you could try to convince me otherwise. First you could "Top balance" your pack as well you can, discharge and recharge. If you have indeed managed to "Top balance" your cells they should all become full at exactly the same time, each and every time. In other words, if "Top balancing" works you'd need to do it only once, just like you only need to Bottom balancing once. From what I've gathered this is not so. And if it isn't, then it doesn't really work. You may think they're all full and balanced at the Top, but what you're really measuring is charge voltage. Nothing else.

Another test I'd like you to do is to "Top balance" your pack as well as you can and then disconnect the whole pack from everything, including BMS and any load. Completely isolated. Let it rest a day or two. Record voltages from each cell. Are they the same? If not, they cannot be at the same State of Charge. Open circuit voltage seems to be indicative or charge state, but only when left disconnected for a long time. This is because the Lithium ions need to settle before the reading is realiable and also the reason why "Top balancing" based on charge voltage doesn't seem to be based on anything.

If you are a proponent of Cell drift, which I haven't seen at all, I'd like to keep those cells disconnected and record the voltage of each cell once a day for as long as you can bother. If cell drift does exist and is measurable, you should see your cell voltages start to go down and differ from each other. Ideally this should be done on a new pack which hasn't been massaged to death by excessive periods of "Top balancing". This is because I'm pretty sure you can see the cells doing all kinds of weird things if you've been torturing them by cooking them at say four volts for days.


Disclaimer: All of my battery ramblings are based on my own experience and Jack Rickard's findings. They are applicable to CALB SE- and CA-series cells. Other cells and chemistries may at least require different voltages.

maanantai 8. huhtikuuta 2013

Why you shouldn't fully charge your cells

In my previous entry I wrote about the Swedish paper on Lithium battery cycle life. I kept thinking about the results and came to an interesting conclusion on why you really shouldn't fully charge your cells.

Consider a scenario like the one in the paper where you would Top Balance your cells and fully recharge them to 100% state of charge every time and then discharge them to empty. You'd be at 80% capacity in about 2000 cycles as expected.

But if you didn't fully charge your cells, but instead chose to undercharge your cells like we do in addition to Bottom Balancing? You might not see the 9000 cycles that they got when they only charged to 50% SOC, but I'd bet you'd get to 6000 easy. Even that would be triple compared to Top Balancing.

In order to get maximum range a lot of people will Top Balance, use a BMS or try to find other ways to maximize their traction pack capacity, for example by trying to even the cell charges on the fly. What they don't realise is that if you try to push as much into the cells as you can you are killing them much faster than you could be.

By 1000 cycles of 100% charging you'll have less capacity in the cells that you would have had if you just undercharged them in the first place. And the loss is permanent. There's no way to get them back. Undercharge and those cells will have that 90% charge much longer than the fully charged, Top Balanced pack takes to reach 80% capacity.

Top Balancing might give you the maximum range right now, but after a couple of thousand cycles they guy who only charged to 90% will probably have longer range and healthier cells.

If you have more money than you can ever use, or happen to sell batteries, then Top Balancing is for you. Otherwise, in the long run, undercharging is the smart thing to do. Don't forget to Bottom Balance.

Update! Here's a link to the paper: http://komar.bitcheese.net/files/JensGroot.pdf

Disclaimer: All of my battery ramblings are based on my own experience and Jack Rickard's findings. They are applicable to CALB SE- and CA-series cells. Other cells and chemistries may at least require different voltages.

On swelling and battery life



Ok, I'll just steal that one from Jack's University of Batteries, but I do think it holds true. Swelling is telling and if your cells swell you are damaging them. Hence there is no need to bind them together tight, unless you want to destroy them by overcharging or, oh, let's say by Top Balancing, which really is just a form of doing that.

Another very, very interesting thing is the excellent paper from Sweden Jack is also kind enough to present to us. What's apparent is that to get the 2000-3000 cycle cell life (down to 80% capacity) you need to continously charge to 100% and discharge to about 10%. I think you'll get the same results by Top Balancing as well if you boil your cells at 100% SOC for extended periods of time. And every time you charge to 100% you're harming the cell, so it's really better to Bottom Balance and undercharge a little, say by charging to 3.5 volts per cell. It's the best way to take of your cells really. You only charge them to a voltage and stop immediately.

The test went on to 9000 cycles with LiPO cells in cyclic simulated EV use before the 80% capacity limit, if you didn't charge them over 50%. It didn't matter how fast you discharged. They lasted better if you went from 23 degrees Celsius to 35 degrees. I know it's LiPO cells, but they should be similar enough for all this to apply to LiFePO4 cells as well. Nothing whatsoever in there that would support anything the BMS people are claiming.

I'd go as far as claiming that if you only have 80% capacity left after only 2000 cycles you've probably been doing something wrong. If you are using a BMS then it's your BMS that is harming your cells.

Another thing to take home here is that discharge rate doesn't matter, which means I'm definitely going to remove any artificial current limits in my motorcycle right away. The SE40AHA cells can put out 400 A, that's 10 C, and I'm going to take it all. My AXE7245 controller could go up to 450 A. I will add some cooling though, I have a 8" fan and a 3" marine blower that I'll be experimenting with, but more on that later.

maanantai 25. maaliskuuta 2013

What's wrong with Top Balancing

Let's go over the basics again. Top Balancing is based on a belief that you can fully charge a cell by charging it to a certain voltage, say 3.65 volts, and just keep it there. To get a complete pack "balanced" would require to charge until all cells are at 3.65 volts. To do this some cells need to be kept at 3.65 volts while others catch up. That's all part of Top Balancing and what many BMS do.

So how did they come up with this system that many people swear by and even think to be absolutely necessary? They probably don't know themselves, but here's how I think it must have happened. We know that a LiFePO4 cell likes to stay within a certain voltage range. Go below 2.5 V and you start hurting the cell. Go above 4 V and you're definitely hurting it. To charge a battery you put current into it and since you know you don't want to go over a certain voltage you stop when it's reached. This was 4.2 V in the beginning, but I guess they've found it a little too high since 3.65 V is what most recommend now. They also found out that if you taper the current you can put a little more energy into the cell while keeping the voltage at 3.65 V.

Now think of Lead Acid for a moment. In Lead Acid voltage is voltage and voltage is charge level. You charge and you keep trickle charging your Lead Acid batteries, they'll be happy for it and you get a nicely Top Balanced Lead Acid pack. The more energy you can put into them the happier they are and the more range you will get from you Lead Sled.

Now if you put these two things together, maximum charge voltage and Lead Acid heritage, what you get is Top Balancing and what usually is considered to be a Lithium BMS. To prove this they talk about stuff like Cell Drift and Self Discharge. I really don't know how they came up with them, but it must be from Lead Acid heritage as well. Or maybe they put this Top Balancing BMS on their cells, kept recording the voltages and noticed that they vary and the cells will Self Discharge.

What they didn't think of was that they had the BMS connected the whole time and both phenomena were actually caused by the BMS itself. If you put any Cell Level system on your cells that's not very, very carefully designed not to draw any (and I do mean any) current, you will see the cells react and they will react differently. You will place on uneven load on the cells that will cause "Cell Drift" and the load itself will be the "Self Discharge" you see. To make matters worse, if you Top Balance and keep cells at 3.65 V while other catch up, you will damage your cells and damage them by different amounts, which will only inflate the problems you think are caused by the cells themselves.

But what about internal resistance, you ask. What about it? What part of Top Balancing BMS will have any effect on the internal resistance of the cell? Yes, the cells may have varying internal resistance and that variation will cause them to discharge at a different rate. Let's say you have a pack of cells and you'd charge them each individually to 3.65 volts without damaging them by "boiling" some at that voltage while others catch up. You'd end up with fully charged cells, right? Now what happens when you start discharging them as hard as you can? You know they have different internal resistance and slight variation in capacity, because they just can't make them perfect yet.

So you're discharging and discharging and your first cells hit the cut-off voltage. You have to stop now, or you'll damage those cells. And you'll better be quick about it too. Stop the car immediately. If you were smart you had already put the vehicle into a Crawl Mode, so that you could pull over safely. Unless you've kept a really good track of previous full discharges you won't know when your first cells will be empty and when you should start crawling. Doing so gets really complicated and expensive really fast. Add in all the single cell level monitoring, shunts to enable Top Balancing and it's not really hard to imagine why those BMS systems are so expensive.

Hopefully I've by now convinced you of the problems with and caused by Top Balancing. I'd really like the whole world to get a clue on this, including Boeing and the BMS people at Sähköautot - Nyt! forum, but I don't have my hopes up. What's amazing is how firmly rooted these false beliefs are. It may just be that a lot of people have too much invested in BMS systems to admit there are issues. It sure does seem like a lot of people are looking to make a buck on these.

I guess I still have the obvious question unanswered. If Top Balancing doesn't do what people think it does and if it doesn't really solve anything, what is the answer? How about if we try something quite opposite. Instead of trying to Top Balance the cells we drain them as empty as we dare. 2.5 volts is a little dangerous so let's say 2.75 volts. Let's call that empty, or close enough.

Now if we have all of our cells empty and we connect them in series with just the interconnects we have an empty pack. What happens if we charge them? They will all receive the same amount of current. They're all a little bit different so they absorb their share a little differently, but it doesn't matter. We don't like any cells to go above into dangerous territory so we undercharge a little. We don't even pretend to get all cells at exactly 3.65 volts. Most end up a little below and some may even go a little higher, but it doesn't matter. We accomplish this by charging the whole series pack to cell count times 3.5 volts. My experience is that even with this undercharge you will end up putting as much or even more energy into the cells than what they are rated for.

What you've in essence accomplished by this Bottom Balancing is that you've zeroed all the differences between the cells, whether it be capacity or internal resistance. When you discharge the cells they will do the same thing in reverse that they did when you charged them and if you keep discharging them they will all end up at the same voltage you Bottom Balanced them at. In other words they will both charge and discharge very close the same way. Close enough that it doesn't matter. As a bonus you don't have to keep track of your cells. You'll now exactly how many Ah went into the pack when you charged it and you know exactly how much you can take out. And once those cells hit that 2.5 volts, all together, at the same time, they will be putting out hardly any energy at all. And since they're all empty they can't force each other into destruction.

Disclaimer: All of my battery ramblings are based on my own experience and Jack Rickard's findings. They are applicable to CALB SE- and CA-series cells. Other cells and chemistries may at least require different voltages.

perjantai 15. helmikuuta 2013

Cell drift

Or lack thereof. Yesterday, when the thermometer showed 0 degrees Celsius (or 32 Fahrenheit), I figured it would be time to go check the cells in my kWsaki electric motorcycle. I took the bike off insurance October 3rd so it's been sitting in the cold garage for about four and a half months. I gave one of the TTL-200C motors a quick spin with the kWsaki traction pack and controller, but I haven't recharged since October.

And when I said cold I meant it. The temperature here has regularly been below zero Fahrenheit and the cells have had to endure it. So I was a little excited when I started the measurements. First cell 3.299 V, second 3.299 V, no make it 3.300 V, next 3.299 V, 3.300 V, 3.300 V and so on. It got really boring really fast. I got a little bit of variance when I couldn't reach the terminals of a couple cells and I had to measure them in pairs. They read 6.61 V. A couple cells showed 3.31 V. This was after I had changed the meter's resolution from 0.000 to 00.00. The whole pack registered at 82.8 volts. For 25 cells that's 3.312 V each.

Considering that the meter is no Fluke and it showed a maximum variance of hundredth of a volt, I don't see evidence of cell drift. I've had nothing connected to the pack for these last months. Note that this is the same pack that I pushed down to 2 volts per cell earlier. If I had damaged any of the cells, they probably wouldn't be happily floating at 3.3 volts after being left to their own devices for months.

Conclusions are that cell drift has not been demonstrated and bottom balancing still seems to work.

If I had more money than I can spend, I could have gotten another 25 cells, put a MiniBMS on them and let them idle for over four months. Alas I do not, but the result is easy to guess. Anyone care to prove me wrong?

sunnuntai 20. tammikuuta 2013

How To Bottom Balance

Warning! This article is about LiFePO4 cells. Some of it may or may not apply to other chemistries.

My earlier post on bottom balancing was long and mainly about why to do it. So I figured I might do a little step by step for those who just want to get it done without delving into the philosophy behind.
  1. Drain all of your cells down to 2.75 volts. Note that the cells will bounce back after you disconnect the load. Repeat the discharge until each cell standing alone stays at 2.75 V.
  2. Connect your cells to each other. Do not connect anything else between the cells but the bars, straps or fuses connecting cells to each other. Do not install BMS. Do not connect any other wires. Strictly cell interconnects only.
  3. Charge the battery pack to a voltage of 3.5 to 3.55 volts times cell count. Examples: 25 cells = 87.6 volts = 3.50 per cell, 33 cells = 116.8 volts = 3.54 per cell. Use CC/CV profile which is the default in many LiFePO4 chargers. End charge when total voltage is reached.
  4. Always discharge the pack as a whole. Always charge the pack as a whole, the same way as described above. Never put any load on only a part of the pack, no matter how small. Never install cell level monitoring or BMS which put any load on individual cells.
If you do this right you shouldn't need to repeat it. If you want, you can periodically drain your pack and measure the voltages. They should all be about the same. If you notice irregularities they are most likely caused by bad cells. Replace bad cells and repeat the bottom balancing for the whole pack.

Bottom balancing is not negligence. Bottom balancing is utmost cell care. You drain them one by one, manually or with a device like Revolectrix PowerLab. While you do that you will spot bad cells quite surely. When you charge them you end the charge well before overcharge and the charge is controlled by the one device which does it best, the charger. As an extra precaution you may also consider adding a meter which disengages the main contactor if pack voltage is not within limits.

On discharge you set your controller to a low voltage limit of over 2 volts per cell (for example, 60 V for 25 cells, 80 V for 33 cells, perhaps even lower). This will prevent any cell going too low, since they all empty at the same time. Since they're all empty they can't harm each other.

Fires happen when cells get overcharged. Bottom balancing doesn't cause overcharging.

Disclaimer: All of my battery ramblings are based on my own experience and Jack Rickard's original work on the subject. They are applicable to CALB SE- and CA-series cells. Other cells and chemistries may at least require different voltages. I take no responsibility for any problems or damage caused by anyone.

torstai 8. marraskuuta 2012

Bottom balancing

Warning! This article is about LiFePO4 cells. Some of it may apply to other chemistries, but YMMV.

Edit: I've also written a short How To Bottom Balance. You should still read this too.

I've talked about this before, but I realised I don't have a single, nice post about the matter that I could refer to when needed. Hence this post. All said only applies to current LiFePO4 cells. Embrace yourself.

Bottom Balancing (BB) is an alternative to Battery Management Systems (BMS). BMS is traditionally a system which includes a little device connected to each individual cell. That little device will monitor the voltage of each cell and also alert the master board, charger or controller if the voltage drops below or exceeds preset values. While charging the device can also shunt the cell effectively forcing it to stay at a preset voltage level while other cells catch up. This is called Top Balancing.

Sounds good, doesn't it? I thought so too. A nice device you can buy, maybe a little expensive, but still solves all battery related problems nice and clean. Keeps good care of your cells, controls charging, protects from over discharge and so on.

Not so.

Turns out Top Balancing and by extension BMS is based on part fantasy and part lead acid heritage. It assumes that you can tell everything just by looking at the current voltage of the cell at any point in time and every state of charge. It also assumes you can get maximum potential out of your cells by boiling them at the highest allowed voltage and even balance them by doing so. Perhaps even refresh them to full capacity.

The truth is far from all these things. The only way to determine state of charge from the cell voltage is to let it sit for a day or two and then measure the voltage down to accuracy of 0.001 volts. Put any load on the cell and you no longer have a realiable reading. Put any charge on the cell and the same thing happens. The cell voltage will sag under load and rise during charge. If you have Top Balanced the cells, which always have different state of charge, will even react by different amount.

What this leads to is that reading cell voltage in these situations is completely useless. If you can't determine your state of charge (SOC) from the reading how could you control your charging or discharging by looking at these values. You just can't.

Even if you assumed that Top Balancing would work and you could even out the differences in cell capacity at the top you would have a problem. The problem would manifest itself when the first cell, the weakest one in your pack, gets near empty. Due to the nature of the LiFePO4 charge and discharge curve, which is very flat for about 90% of the cell charge and very steep at both ends, you end up with that weak cell plummeting in voltage.

If your BMS is fast enough it will disconnect the pack and save the cell. If not, the single cell will keep going down, kill itself and possibly even it's friends nearby by going into reversal or even swelling rapidly. Even worse there's no way to know when this will happen. The exact moment of weakest cell going empty is unpredictable so you end up using such a big safety margin that you're not even using th  pack to it's fullest. Add into account the fact that high load will exaggerate the voltage drop and you end up in a situation where you or your BMS can't know what's really going on. Your vehicle either stops sooner than it should have or it breaks down.

Charging is pretty much the same in reverse. You try to fill up each by thinking that if you get all of them to say 3.65 volts they will be as full as they can be and they don't mind waiting for their buddies. It sort of works, because the cell voltage will start to climb when the cell gets fuller, but trying to top them like this achieves nothing and there is a possibility you might also be hurting your cells if you do this. Charging is less critical because it usually happens much slower than discharging. You can charge at say 20 amps, but you may discharge at 1000 amps. Things happen so much faster at 1000 amps.

Because we know that cell state of charge can be measured when the cell has rested, and especially when it's very near empty, we can try something different. Instead of trying to balance the cells at the top by forcing them to a certain voltage we drain them. We drain them down to about 2.75 volts. That's well in the steep downwards part of the discharge curve. Well enough to be a reliable indication of state of charge, but not too far to be dangerous to the cell.

When draining you need to drain the cells a little below 2.75 V, let them bounce back to a little above 2.75 V and then repeat until the cell doesn't bounce anymore, but stays at about 2.75 V even after a period of rest. Once you have done this on all of your cells and removed any load from them you can be quite sure that they are now all at the same state of charge very near empty. Bottom Balanced, that is. We have taken all the cells, independent of their actualy capacity to the same line and we can now charge them. But not one by one.

In order to charge this Bottom Balanced pack it is vitally important that you connect the cells and only the cells, nothing else, to each other. You cannot put anything else on the cell terminals except the strap or a copper bar that connects it to the next cell. If you do put something else you will ruin the Bottom Balancing and you will either have to start from the beginning or not have balanced pack anymore.

Once you have all the cells connected to each other forming a pack, all cells still at 2.75 volts, undisturbed, you can start charging them. But only as a whole. You can never ever charge or discharge only a part of the pack or you must start over again (and do not pass go). Since we know that the manufacturers recommend that most LiFePO4 cells not be charged over 3.65 volts to prevent damage we leave a little headroom and charge to a total voltage which is 3.5-3.55 volts times cell count.

Now you may think your giving up something when you're not charging to 3.65 volts. And you are correct. But it's not nearly as much as you'd think. The charge curve is mostly almost flat and only starts to rise at the very end. And it does rise fast. So fast even that you're putting very little energy into the cells when it starts to rise above 3.4 V. What that means is that the amount of miles you are losing is insignificant. Instead it gives our pack a little room to breathe and a safety margin which is needed, because the weakest cells will rise in voltage first. Just like they would die first if you were Top Balancing.

So how do we know when to end the charge? It's very easy. You either pick a charger that has a maximum charge voltage of 3.55 times cell count or choose you cell count based on a charger you can get. I prefer the latter and use a 116.8 volt charger for 33 cells and a 87.6 volt charger for 25 cells. Thats 3.54 or 3.50 volts per cell, respectively. While charging each cell will receive exactly as much charge as the next. At the end of the charge the weakest cells will rise in voltage a bit more than the best, but nowhere near enough to damage them. When enough cells reach a higher voltage the charger will cut the charge as the total charge voltage has been reached.

The chargers currently used do a CC/CV charge, which means that the charger charges at full amps until a set voltage is reached and the holds that voltage by lowering the current until the current drops to about 5% of full current. The last CV phase accounts for 10-20% of the charge depending on cell type. There is now talk of dropping the CV phase completely with the latest cells and only doing the CC phase, which would only give us a 90% charge, but it would happen fast and might save the cells even more than is generally believed. Thus keeping that 90% range for a longer time instead of dropping to say 80% over time.

This charging that I've described here is just a procedure. It's a way to charge the cells. Once the charge has been cut and you have let the cells rest you will observe that they dropped in voltage to about 3.4 volts each. This is the voltage of a fully charged cell. We simply used a slightly higher average voltage to get them there and did this in series to make sure they all got the same amount of current.

We haven't reached the best part of Bottom Balancing yet. It's so obvious to me I almost forgot to write about it even though it's the main reason why we do it.

The magic of Bottom Balancing happens when you run out of juice. As we drained all cells in the pack to the same voltage and have only charged them together they will also reach empty at the same time. There are two benefits in this. First, since they do it simultaneously and since we are at the steep end of the curve there will be hardly any energy left in them so eventually the vehicle will not move anymore. You start to feel this in you accelerator pedal or twist grip before it happens because you start losing power so you can drive to the side of the road safely instead of the car stopping completely and unexpectedly as would happen with a BMS.

Secondly, and quite importantly, the cells, in harmony, will protect each other. Since none of them have much energy left in them they don't have the power to kill their buddies either. In the BMS based Top Balancing scenario the weakest cell will be violently attacked by the other cells, which still have a lot of power left, by trying to extract as much energy from that weak cell as they are able to produce themselves.

In order to prevent a careless driver from eventually harming the cells by keeping the pedal pressed to the floor even though the vehicle isn't even moving anymore, we program a low voltage limit into the controller. This can be as low as 2 volts times cell count, but you can define it higher if you wish to leave more margin. I have personally tested a 2 volt setting (25 cells, 50 volt limit) on a motorcycle and the cells suffered no harm although I repeatedly hit that 50 volt limit. In fact they bounced back to safe territory some time after the load had been removed.

So there. Didn't come out very short, but that's my view of Bottom Balancing and why it works. YMMV.

ps. The so-called "Cell Drift" has not been observed at all when Bottom Balancing. Therefore it has been concluded that these cells do not drift by themselves. Any observed drift has been caused by the BMS themselves or cell level monitoring which loads the cells unevenly. There is no reason to fight "Cell Drift" by installing equipment which will in fact cause it, unnecessarily wear out the cells and even cause a fire hazard thanks to a mess of spaghetti wiring.

Disclaimer: All of my battery ramblings are based on my own experience and Jack Rickard's original work on the subject. They are applicable to CALB SE- and CA-series cells. Other cells and chemistries may at least require different voltages. I take no responsibility for any problems or damage caused by anyone.

tiistai 18. syyskuuta 2012

Bottom balancing to the rescue

Last night I rode my battery pack half empty and today added the 25th cell that arrived yesterday. I then proceeded to drive the pack completely empty so I could bottom balance the new cell as well. I dropped off some badges my S.O. had made, located a gas station not to fill up but to check tire pressure, picked up two salads from the local market and ran out of juice before getting home. Yes, I thought the pack would have 5 Ah more left, but alas it did not. I kept pushing against the 50 volt limit I had set in the controller, that's only 2 volts per cell, but couldn't get home without pushing for real.

I was more than a little worried that I had incorrectly estimated the state of charge of the new cell and now ruined it straight away, but it was not so. It was happily resting at 3.2 volts while the rest of the pack was around 2.5 volts per cell. I didn't take very long to go from very worried to very happy about how well bottom balancing had protected my precious cells. I hadn't been able to break them even by pushing them down to 2 volts. And I tried. The bike would just stop going as the cells refused to give more than a few amps and floated back from their lower limits with no problems whatsoever. I can therefore testify that bottom balanced cells will protect each other and not let you kill their colleagues.


I then turned my attention to the newcomer and drained it down to about 2.5 volts where the older cells were waiting, connected my 2 kW charger and let it do it's thing. About 40 Ah went in as expected. For the bottom balancing I used the electric motor of the bike itself.

maanantai 17. syyskuuta 2012

Missing cell: Arrived

Finally got my last cell today from faktor.de. It arrived at about 3.276 V. Perhaps a little less than half charged then. I'll now have to drain the main pack before I can add the newcomer into it. It will also need to be drained to 2.7 V initially. I might want to improve upon my earlier bottom balancing on all of the old cells as well. When I did it for the first time I eventually ran out of patience. That's not to say bottom balancing hasn't been working perfectly. It has.


perjantai 24. elokuuta 2012

25th element

No, it's not a Luc Besson movie. I wouldn't mind if it was, they're great, but it's a cell. I now have 24 cells and a 87.6 volt charger. That makes 3.65 volts per cell as the charging voltage. CALB recommends 3.6, but with bottom balancing you want to leave a bit more headroom to protect the cells. With 25 I'd get to 3.5 which is ideal. Hence the 25th element. If I can't find one used I'll have to order. The postage will be one fourth of the whole price, but it cannot be helped.

At 3.5 I will sacrifice some SOC (State of Charge) in order to make the cells last longer and also make them stay better balanced. Right now three of my 24 cells can get up to 4 volts while charging which is way too much. They drop back into line quickly after the charge ends, but it still makes me uncomfortable. The extra cell needs to find a place somewhere, but I'm sure I'll figure it out. I should also see a couple of kilometers more range, which never hurts.

Something I realized about charging. It's just a voltage per cell. It's not a target. It's just means to an end. Sure, it won't be exceeded, but it's really the current that counts. How you should charge these LiFePO4 cells is with constant voltage and a constant current until at the end when the current should gradually drop until the pack is deemed full enough. It's quite possibly the only "BMS" you need. At least for the charging phase. Of course you should make sure you don't charge when it's too cold, or too hot for that matter, and make sure your charger is reliable enough not to exceed the set voltage and also ends the charge when due.

As for protecting the battery when discharging it's really where the magic of bottom balancing happens. If you've carefully drained your cells to the same limit below three volts before using them they should all also return to that same voltage on each and every full discharge. For a bit of additional protection I've set my controller, the AXE7245, to a low voltage limit of 60 volts. That's 2.5 volts per cell. It should be quite improssible to kill any cells this way. At least if a cell dies despite these precautions it really was a bad cell and should be put away anyway. No amount of active BMS could have saved it.

That's all there is to it really. Some human-based BMS logic is needed not to do anything stupid and keeping an eye on the cells for any physical defects, but we're just fine this way. If I was building a car with a larger battery pack, and I'm not saying I wouldn't be, someday, and especially if it was for someone else, I might consider some electronics to keep an eye on the minimum and maximum voltages. Perhaps battery pack temperature as well. Just to be safe and catch a few situations that might occur when you have more voltage and the cells are hidden out of sight. On a motorcycle, there's just no need.